Fixing an Inaccurate Criminal Record in a Background Check
Background-check errors are corrected at two levels: the consumer reporting agency that produced the report must reinvestigate a dispute under the Fair Credit Reporting Act, and the court or repository holding the source record must fix the underlying file. The employer that ordered the report cannot edit it, but must follow required notice steps before acting on it.
A background check that contains the wrong information is a data problem, and data problems have owners. Under the federal Fair Credit Reporting Act (FCRA), the consumer reporting agency that produced the report — the company that assembled and sold the background check — must investigate a dispute and correct or delete inaccurate items. The court or state repository that created the underlying record is responsible for fixing that record at its source. The employer or landlord who ordered the report generally cannot edit it; its obligations lie in how it uses the report.
Those layers are independent, which is what confuses people. A commercial background check company typically buys criminal case data from a courthouse index, a state repository, or another data aggregator rather than directly from the FBI. A courthouse can correct its file and the report will stay wrong until the company that sold it updates its copy. A reporting agency can also delete an item while the underlying court record remains unchanged.
The answer to "who fixes this" is therefore usually two entities: the agency that issued the report, and the government office holding the source record. Both processes can be started by the person named in the record.
How a criminal record travels
A single case can end up in several separate systems, each keeping its own copy:
- Trial courts. The docket and the disposition — the final outcome of a case, such as a dismissal, acquittal, plea, or conviction — are the primary record of what happened.
- State repositories. Most states maintain a central criminal history repository, commonly run by the state police or a state bureau of investigation, which receives arrest and disposition reports from local agencies.
- The FBI. State repositories forward fingerprint-based records to the FBI, which maintains the national Identity History Summary, sometimes called a criminal history record or "rap sheet."
- Commercial consumer reporting agencies. These private companies compile background check reports for employers and landlords. They may buy bulk data from courts, repositories, or aggregators, or send researchers to courthouses.
An error can enter at any step, and each system corrects only its own records. A disposition that was never forwarded, a case filed under a similar name, or a charge listed without its outcome can survive in one layer long after being fixed in another.
Step one: dispute the report with the reporting agency
The FCRA gives consumers the right to dispute information in a consumer report, and it requires the reporting agency to reinvestigate. There is no required form. A dispute tends to be most effective when it identifies the item precisely and explains in plain language why it is inaccurate.
- Obtain the report and identify exactly what it says, including the case number, court, date, and charge.
- State the specific inaccuracy: a dismissed charge shown as a conviction, a case belonging to a different person, or a disposition that does not match the docket.
- Attach documentation. A certified copy of the disposition, a letter from the clerk of court, or an identity theft report are the documents agencies most often request.
- Send the dispute in writing to the address the agency lists for disputes, and keep a copy and proof of delivery.
- Keep the agency's written response. Under Legal Information Institute (15 U.S.C. § 1681i), the agency generally must complete its reinvestigation within 30 days, a period that can extend to 45 days if the consumer supplies more information during the initial 30 days.
- If an item is changed or deleted, the agency must generally notify anyone who received the report within a set look-back period, which is longer for reports used for employment.
Filing a dispute is free, and the same right applies to tenant screening reports and other consumer reports used for eligibility decisions.
Step two: correct the source record
Court records
If the docket itself is wrong, the correction begins with the clerk of the court that handled the case. Clerks routinely fix clerical errors, such as a misspelled name or a mistyped date, and can supply a certified copy showing the accurate entry. Substantive changes are different: a record that is legally accurate but should no longer be publicly available is addressed through sealing or expungement, which requires a court order under state law. Once an order is granted, certified copies usually need to be sent to the state repository, in some cases the FBI, and to any background check company still reporting the case.
State repositories and the FBI
State criminal history repositories generally have a record review or challenge process for people who believe their state record contains inaccurate or incomplete information, and the FBI describes a procedure for reviewing and challenging an Identity History Summary. A challenge usually requires proof of identity, fingerprints, and court documents showing the correct disposition.
Errors that appear most often
- The same name and date of birth attached to another person's case.
- A dismissal, acquittal, or nolle prosequi (a decision not to prosecute) reported as a conviction.
- A charge listed with no disposition, so the case appears unresolved.
- A sealed or expunged case still reported by a commercial agency.
- Duplicate entries for the same arrest.
- A misdemeanor described as a felony, or a charge described more severely than the docket shows.
What the employer is responsible for
An employer that uses a consumer report for an employment decision must follow the FCRA's adverse action process. Before taking adverse action based in whole or in part on the report, the employer must give the person a copy of the report, a written summary of FCRA rights, and a reasonable chance to respond. If the employer proceeds, it must provide notice of the decision afterward. Employers are not required to verify the accuracy of a report before using it, but the pre-adverse action notice is what allows an error to be raised before a decision becomes final. The Equal Employment Opportunity Commission has published enforcement guidance on how criminal record screening intersects with federal anti-discrimination law.
Agency by agency: who owns the fix
| Type of error | Who initiates the fix | Typical starting step |
|---|---|---|
| Another person's case reported under the same name | Consumer reporting agency | Written dispute identifying the mismatch |
| Dismissal or acquittal reported as a conviction | Consumer reporting agency | Certified disposition sent with the dispute |
| Incorrect docket entry (clerical) | Court clerk | Request for correction and a certified copy |
| Case that should be sealed or expunged | Court, by order | State sealing or expungement procedure |
| Order granted but record still reported | Repository, FBI, or agency holding it | Certified copy of the order sent to each holder |
| Arrest with no recorded outcome | Court and reporting agency | Documentation of the disposition or non-filing |
When the record is someone else's
Criminal identity theft — where another person is arrested using your name and identifiers — produces records that look like yours. IdentityTheft.gov is the federal site where a report can be filed and an identity theft report generated. Federal law also provides a process for blocking information in a consumer report that resulted from identity theft when the consumer supplies an identity theft report and identifying information to the reporting agency.
Where this varies
Nearly everything described here comes from a mix of federal and state law, so details change by jurisdiction and by court. Under Legal Information Institute, federal law generally limits how long most adverse items other than convictions may be reported, while a number of states impose shorter limits that also cover convictions. Expungement, sealing, and pardon eligibility are defined by state law and vary widely. Court practices for correcting a docket differ from county to county. The dispute duties of consumer reporting agencies come from federal law, but some states add requirements of their own. The state repository process and the FBI process are separate, and fixing one does not automatically update the other.
Because each layer keeps its own copy, a correction at one layer does not automatically reach the others. Certified copies of court documents are the common thread that repositories, the FBI, and background check companies request. The Federal Trade Commission publishes consumer guidance on background check reports, and USA.gov maintains links to prisoner and public records resources.
Browse the directory
Frequently asked questions
Who is responsible for fixing an inaccurate background check?
The consumer reporting agency that produced the report must reinvestigate a dispute and correct or delete inaccurate items under the Fair Credit Reporting Act. The court, repository, or agency holding the source record is responsible for correcting that record. The employer that ordered the report cannot edit it, but must follow required notice steps before acting on it.
Can a background check error be disputed for free?
Yes. Federal law gives consumers the right to dispute information in a consumer report, and the reporting agency must reinvestigate at no charge. Disputes can be sent in writing with supporting documents such as a certified court disposition or an identity theft report. No particular form is required.
How long does a background check dispute take?
Under 15 U.S.C. § 1681i, the reporting agency generally must complete its reinvestigation within 30 days, and that period can extend to 45 days if the consumer provides additional information during the initial 30 days. Court processes for correcting a docket follow their own timelines.
What happens if the court record itself is wrong?
The correction starts at the clerk's office of the court that handled the case, which can fix clerical errors and issue a certified copy. Changes that remove a legally accurate record from public view, such as sealing or expungement, require a court order under state law.
Does expungement automatically remove a record from background checks?
Not automatically. A court order applies to the court's file and generally must be sent to state repositories, in some cases the FBI, and to commercial reporting agencies. Because each system keeps its own copy, a record may continue to appear until each holder updates it.
What if the criminal record belongs to someone else?
Criminal identity theft can attach another person's case to your name and identifiers. IdentityTheft.gov is the federal site for filing a report, and federal law provides a process for blocking information in a consumer report that resulted from identity theft when an identity theft report is provided.
Written and reviewed by the InmateSearch.co Editorial Team. This page describes how the process generally works and is not legal advice.
Last reviewed and updated: